Mila Rechcigl as a Social Scientist

Developing Food Security Indicators

One of my chief responsibilities in the 1995-96 period was to develop food security indicators for the Agency. Toward this end I organized in December 1995 a Workshop on FS[2] Performance Measurement under the aegis of CDIE. I served as the workshop coordinator with the help of Margie Ferris-Morris.[3] The primary objective of the workshop was to share information and experience on performance measurement of FS at the operational level, taking stock of how USAID and its implementing partners currently measure their FS programs and to generate a core set of performance indicators that would help demonstrate the impact of non-emergency aid. A two-day workshop was held 11-12 of December, 1995, with the participation of over 120 USAID Washington staff, Missions, implementing partners and other experienced practitioners and WFP, IFPRI, World Bank, and Economic Union, etc.. Key speakers from USAID, PVOs[4] and academia outlined important issues of performance measurement of FS in LDCs. The participants were divided into breakout groups to discuss and generate indicators to measure improved availability of food, improved access to food and improved utilization of food. As a result of this joint effort a draft list of 70 plus indicators was generated.

Following the workshop an additional input on the draft list of indicators was sought from USAID Washington, USAID Missions, PVOs, as well as outside experts, notably World Bank, IFPRI, and IDS. And finally, a technical review group composed of knowledgeable persons from USAID, USDA, IMPACT project, and PVO was convened to finalize the list of recommended indicators. The final document was sent to all USAID Missions, as well as to the Workshop participants and other interested parties.

The document was well received and favorably commented on. One private voluntary organization, CARE, has already adopted the full set of our indicators into their programs. Another PVO, Catholic Relief Service, requested a draft copy to be FAXed to Haiti for immediate use. Those involved in the process expressed gratification with the final product. The true test of its utility awaited the feedback from the field. Several USAID Missions have indicated that as a next step it would be useful to them if a detailed field manual were developed that would enumerate practical steps on collection and interpretation of the data, as well as provide other practical information regarding the availability and reliability of the data sources. The Workshop Proceedings which were under preparation should be particularly useful to the Missions and implementing partners in providing better understanding of the context and the issues that led to the selection of the FS indicators at the operational level.

At the recommendation of the original Agency-wide working group it was decided to form a separate Task Force, which I also coordinated, that would work concurrently on the FS indicators at the Agency level. Task Force included Gerald Britan (PPC/CDIE), E. Chung (G/PHN), Bruce Cogill (IMPACT), Ralph Cummings (GIEG), Nils Daulaire (PPC/PHD), Carl Mabbs-Zeno (PPC/ECON), Francesca Nelson (BHR/PPE), Shirley Pryor (GIEG), Lisa Smith (PPC/PHD), Roberta Van Haeften (LAC/DR), Kimberely van Wagner (PPC/CDIE/DI), Jim Vermillion (PPC/DEM), Carolyn Weiskirch (PPC/HR), and David Whyner (PPC/ENV).

Various indicators were proposed, discussed and researched that would allow measurements of trends in countries' performance towards enhancing food security for their populations. A number of external and internal discussions of the proposed indicators took place over several months and external experts were consulted. The Task Force considered the best indicators that are reflective of improved FS in a broad context - encompassing improved availability, access and utilization of food, as well as sustainability aspects. At the conclusion of its deliberations, the Task Force came up with a recommended set of common indicators for FS at the Agency level. The set included one overall indicator for FS plus six specific indicators for measuring food availability, food access, food utilization, and sustainability. The basis for selection of the indicators was the desirability to develop a core set of common indicators that could be tracked and compared across countries to ascertain progress toward enhancement of FS.

Furthermore, the Task Force concluded that it would be in the Agency's interest to set up and institutionalize a system that would assure a systematic collection of data on FS across countries to give USAID a comprehensive overview of the progress made in this area.

There still remained the vexing question where FS fits in the Agency structural framework. The question has been raised repeatedly and it was understood that the Agency, sooner or later, will need to take grip of this issue. In this connection it is of interest that Administrator Atwood at one of the BIFAD meetings, made a special reference to the importance of FS, implying that more emphasis may be placed on agriculture and agricultural research in USAID programs.

Bearing this in mind, I developed, with the help of Margie Ferris-Morris, a series of conceptual and structural framework charts linking FS to the Agency programs. Although there was no separate "home" for FS in the USAID programs, it was clear that FS cuts horizontally across most of the Agency priority areas, including Economic Growth, Environment, Population and Health, and Humanitarian Assistance.

The above work was recognized by PPC advisors as a worthy endeavor and received universal praise throughout the Agency.

I’d like to conclude this chapter with the evaluation Carolyn Weiskirch[5] sent of me to my supervisor:

To: Gerry Britan

From: Carolyn Weiskirch

Subject: re: 360 Degree Input[6]

Date: Monday, August 19, 1996 12:50:16 EDT

Gerry:

It is my pleasure to contribute to Mike Rechcigl’s 360! (7)

The past year was a very interesting year as far as the agency and its perception of food security and how to measure it. Having worked in this area for some years, I had become accustomed to us making very little headway, if any at all, while people violently disagreed with each other, resulting in hard feelings and little else.

Well, that was the past! Thanks to Mike Rechcigl, the Agency has now traveled light years in less than 12 months! Taking a common sense, clear-minded approach, he developed and managed to put on a workshop that worked superbly well. He broadened the “usual participation” to bring in new blood /people with a variety of good ideas. He managed an agenda and discussion groups, where these many times conflicting ideas were actually discussed, not attacked. He coped beautifully with some pretty big egos, too! And, he achieved results! His workshop has been followed by continuing dialogue on the indicators, measuring performance and other aspects of food security. It continues even now.

I personally think that Mike Rechcigl, in his low key and perceptive manner, has done a magnificent job doing something that no one thought could be done. And, this was all Mike...no one else! To me, he represents the best of re-engineering principles – participation, openness and transparency, accountability and, of course, results. He’s a terrific team player and a great person to work with.

Carolyn

Back to top ↑

Endnotes

  1. [1] This is based on one of my reports to the Agency. I purposely left it in the “Governmentese language”, to get the reader an idea how Government bureaucrats communicated among each other.
  2. [2] Food Security
  3. [3] She was under a contract with our Center.
  4. [4] PVO stands for Private Voluntary Organization.
  5. [5] A senior official in PPC.
  6. [6] Evaluation report in the Agency’s lingo.
  7. {7} That's how Mila Rechcigl was initially called